正面对决
| diCleaner | LumaDisk | |
|---|---|---|
| Visualization | List | Sunburst |
| Platform | macOS | macOS + Windows |
| Pricing | Free Free on the Mac App Store at time of writing | Paid Paid one-time purchase (around $7 at time of writing) |
| Open source | No | No |
| Native Mac | Yes | No |
2026年9月更新 · 价格会变,请以供应商为准。
diCleaner
A free all-in-one cleaner with analyzer and menu monitoring.
＋ diCleaner: 优点
- Free entry point covering analyzer, junk, and duplicates
- Menu-bar monitoring for ongoing awareness
- Simple enough for first-time cleaners
－ diCleaner: 缺点
- All-in-one breadth over analyzer depth
- Free cleaners monetize attention — check the upsell path
- No standout visualization for understanding usage
阅读评测: diCleaner → · diCleaner 查看替代品 →
LumaDisk
A light-speed sunburst that turns your filesystem into light.
＋ LumaDisk: 优点
- Modern sunburst visualization on both Mac and Windows
- Fast scans with a clean, contemporary interface
- Affordable one-time price
－ LumaDisk: 缺点
- Cross-platform toolkit feel rather than fully native Mac UI
- Newer app with a shorter track record than incumbents
- Cleanup tooling is lighter than specialist cleaners
阅读评测: LumaDisk → · LumaDisk 查看替代品 →
结论: diCleaner vs LumaDisk
Choose diCleaner if you want list visualization on macOS. Choose LumaDisk if you prefer sunburst views at paid pricing on macOS + Windows. And if you want a native Mac sunburst with a staged collector and zero telemetry, NullDisk is the third option that beats both on workflow.
常见问题
Which is better, diCleaner or LumaDisk?
diCleaner wins on list visualization for macOS; LumaDisk wins on sunburst views for macOS + Windows. On price, Free (diCleaner) vs Paid (LumaDisk). The honest answer depends on your OS and whether you prefer maps or lists — read the verdict below.
Is there something better than both?
If you want a native Mac sunburst with allocated-size honesty, a staged removal collector, and zero data collection, NullDisk beats both on workflow — even where diCleaner or LumaDisk wins on price.